clock menu more-arrow no yes
Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge

Filed under:

Rev transcribers hate the low pay, but the disturbing recordings are even worse

Violent police recordings, descriptions of child abuse, and graphic medical videos have appeared without warning, transcribers say

Content warning: This story contains discussion of abuse and violence.

One transcriber working for Rev says that, for them, the recordings that graphically detail someone being abused or assaulted are the most difficult to get through. For other transcribers at Rev, it¡¯s the videos from police body cams that show dead bodies and people who have been attacked, or files where children talk about where an abuser touched them. ¡°Of course, I have the option not to work on such files, but I have no way of knowing what I¡¯m clicking on until I hear it,¡± the Revver says. A Rev transcriber can choose from a long list of largely unidentified recordings when picking what to work on. The trouble is, a file submitted under the ¡°legal¡± category might be ¡°a corporate law meeting,¡± the Revver says, or ¡°a police recording with someone screaming in distress.¡±

Rev made headlines this month after it slashed minimum pay for its transcribers from 45 cents per audio / video minute transcribed to 30 cents. The company justified the change by saying it was also increasing the pay for more difficult files, and so, ultimately, the amount paid out to transcribers would be about the same. But even though Rev says the changes will only affect a ¡°very small number of jobs,¡± workers say they are seeing substantial pay cuts because of the change ¡ª and for some, the work increasingly isn¡¯t worth the time and stress.

Rev was founded in 2010 and raised $4.5 million in funding over the next couple of years. The San Francisco- and Austin-based company claims to have over 50,000 independent contractors who transcribe audio at a flat rate of $1 per minute, with its list of customers including Amazon, Microsoft, Viacom, and UCLA, among many others. For transcribers, it touts the freedom of setting their own hours, working from home, and getting paid out on a weekly basis. Many of the Revvers The Verge spoke with were initially attracted to the site by these promises. It fills a need for those who can¡¯t hold a traditional job for any number of personal reasons. ¡°So many people that do this job,¡± a Revver says, ¡°They¡¯re caring for elderly parents. They have multiple sclerosis ¡­ They¡¯re just desperately trying to get by.¡±

But over a dozen Revvers, who asked to remain anonymous because they still work on the platform, say that while the work is appealing on the surface, this recent pay cut makes staying on the service hard to justify. Difficult transcription jobs sometimes work out to sub-minimum wage rates, and many transcribers have been exposed to disturbing content without warning.

A normal day transcribing for Rev is mostly filled with boring stuff: meetings, marketing pitches, and company presentations. There are also some fun jobs. Several Revvers say they learned about new podcasts through working on files or liked listening to authors talk about their books. One enjoyed transcribing comedy specials before they aired.

But every so often, Rev transcribers also encounter upsetting content, and having to deal with it unexpectedly and for lower wages makes the work that much harder.

Nearly every Revver who spoke with The Verge said they were exposed to graphic or troubling material on multiple occasions with no warning. This includes recordings of physical and verbal abuse between intimate partners, graphic descriptions of sexual assault, amateur porn, violent footage from police body cameras, a transphobic rant, and, in one instance, ¡°a breast augmentation filmed by a physician¡¯s cell phone, being performed on a patient who was under sedation.¡±

It doesn¡¯t bother everyone, but for some, it can be overwhelming. ¡°I¡¯ve finished more than one file in tears because listening to someone talk about being abused or assaulted is emotionally taxing, and frankly I have no training or expertise that really helps me cope with it,¡± one Revver tells The Verge.

This image contains sensitive or violent content
Tap to display
Many Rev transcribers have posted in the company¡¯s forums asking for content warnings on sensitive files. In some cases, the posts include graphic descriptions of disturbing files they listened to.
This image contains sensitive or violent content
Tap to display
Rev also includes a forum where workers request help transcribing difficult audio. In this case, it¡¯s for a graphic 911 call.

The pay rate assigned to each transcription is variable and set by an algorithm. To pick up work, Revvers comb through a queue of available jobs, and when they find one they want to transcribe, they claim it. They then have a one-hour grace period where, if something comes up or the file is too bothersome, they can throw the file back in the queue without penalty. An AI helps to transcribe audio on some files before it¡¯s given to a person, but Revvers say it¡¯s inconsistent.

Revvers say it¡¯s often unclear what they¡¯re getting into when they start a recording. Usually, the only indicators a Revver has as to what¡¯s inside a file is its title and the name of the person submitting it, should it be a person or entity they recognize. Some clients mark the general category of the job they submit or how many speakers there are, but many don¡¯t or label files incorrectly. That leaves Revvers to do the work of organizing files or warning others of a file¡¯s quality and content ¡ª something they can only do if they¡¯ve already taken time to listen to the recording. ¡°It¡¯s a unique situation because we are direct competitors,¡± says one Revver, ¡°but we will stop and help each other.¡± All of this assistance is done without pay.

One person said they began transcribing a file because it was submitted by an academic institution, only to realize later that it was a Title IX investigation with graphic descriptions of assault. So then they have to make a decision: ¡°I¡¯m already halfway through this, do I bail or do I get through it?¡± they said. ¡°And usually the answer is: I get through it and then I leave the platform for the rest of the day, because when that happens, it fucking sucks.¡±

If the transcriber chooses to not finish a job after the hour-long grace period, they risk receiving a lowered ¡°commitment ratio score¡± in addition to giving up any money they would have made. If a transcriber¡¯s standing goes below a certain threshold, their account can be terminated. ¡°Sometimes you¡¯ll get part way through a file and realize, ¡®Oh, this involves some child abuse,¡¯¡± says another Revver. ¡°And if it¡¯s past the unclaimed time, you can¡¯t [abandon] it.¡±

In an email to The Verge, Rev said that ¡°all files¡± are categorized, but Revvers say this is untrue. Screenshots sent to The Verge show numerous files in Rev¡¯s queue without any subject assigned. ¡°At least 50 percent of them have no subject,¡± one Revver said.

Rev also said that its customers ¡°are prohibited from uploading offensive content¡± and that the company ¡°does not require anyone to work on specific projects.¡± The site¡¯s terms of service agreement says that content can¡¯t be uploaded that is ¡°threatening, abusive, harassing, tortious, excessively violent, defamatory, vulgar, obscene, pornographic, libelous, invasive of another¡¯s privacy, hateful racially, ethnically or otherwise objectionable,¡± but its customers seem to violate the rules. Within the past month, Rev workers have talked about transcribing porn, graphic surgery videos, and domestic violence 911 calls on the company forum.

One Revver said that, just last week, they were at a coffee shop when they opened up a file that turned out to be a documentary on a nudist colony. ¡°Instantly there was a set of genitals right in front of me, completely not covered up. It was a video file and there was definitely no warning at all,¡± the Revver said. ¡°No chance to obscure my screen from any children, baristas, or the security guard at the Starbucks. I had to close my laptop right away because I didn¡¯t want people to think I was looking at porn.¡±

Many Revvers do the work to earn extra money, but for some, this kind of work is a necessity. One Revver The Verge spoke with used the site as a stopgap after losing their full-time job. Others have disabilities and can¡¯t hold full-time jobs. Another uses it to supplement their Social Security. Even with Rev work as a supplement, they say their income is about half the national poverty level.

This image contains sensitive or violent content
Tap to display
A user requests a trigger warning after watching a graphic video.
This image contains sensitive or violent content
Tap to display
Other users discuss content warnings after viewing disturbing footage.

One Revver The Verge spoke with lives in a rural area and is unable to drive for mental health reasons. They have a part-time job that¡¯s a 90-minute walk away, and they are not near a bus line. They signed up for Rev in order to save up for a new bicycle so they could reach their current part-time job and the nearest town more easily. ¡°I have a 35-year-old bicycle,¡± they tell The Verge. ¡°It¡¯s trucking along, but it¡¯s bad with the rain and hills. Rev¡¯s pay keeps dwindling. I can¡¯t buy a new bike now.¡±

The company¡¯s lowered rates spilled over into the public spotlight earlier this month when transcriber Li Zilles tweeted about the change and called it ¡°another example of a gig economy startup brazenly mistreating its workers.¡±

Many Revvers say that the pay was okay before this recent change. They were able to meet their state¡¯s minimum wage (which they are not guaranteed because of the job¡¯s freelance nature), and it was enough to keep them happy. But for several people The Verge spoke with, that¡¯s no longer the case with Rev¡¯s new payment structure. Some transcribers said they couldn¡¯t keep pace with the low federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour. One Revver says their earnings have already decreased by over one-third, and now they fear they might not be able to make rent.

In an email, Rev said that ¡°many skilled transcriptionists on Rev earn $15+ per hour. Slower and less experienced typists earn less.¡± It said jobs are offered at ¡°a wide range of pay rates¡± and are paid per job, not hourly, because the workers are freelance.

A common misconception with transcription is that it doesn¡¯t take that much time or require much expertise. But as many professional longtime transcribers working on Rev tell The Verge, you need good and accurate typing, proofreading, grammar, punctuation, and language skills. Even then, a 15-minute file will likely take someone an hour to transcribe. That¡¯s for clear audio, without much crosstalk, heavy accents, background noise, or the need to fact-check the array of technical words that might pop up in medical or legal files.

Rev says it accounts for these challenges with its algorithm, which supposedly sets higher rates per minute for more difficult files and lower rates for easier ones. But many say the math doesn¡¯t work out, and harder files that take twice as long to transcribe don¡¯t necessarily pay more than twice as much for the effort. The harder jobs can also be more mentally and physically tiring, writes one transcriber in a note published on Gizmodo.

Another Revver who The Verge spoke with summed up the exasperation many feel with the company¡¯s latest changes. ¡°We¡¯re not being recognized ... We get no legal protections. We get nothing,¡± they said.

Revvers have few workplace protections under the law because the company classifies them as independent contractors, according to Veena Dubal, associate professor of law at the University of California, Hastings. ¡°If you are an independent contractor it¡¯s legal to make 1 cent on a job,¡± Dubal says. Simply put, with very limited exceptions, employment and labor law protections don¡¯t apply to independent contractors, so there are no rules in place about how long an independent contractor works or how much or little they make per hour. Rev also states that it has no age limit on who can work as a transcriber, but said in an email that state laws should be followed. ¡°So there may be people under 16 working over 40 hours a week on Rev and that¡¯s not illegal,¡± Dubal says.

Employee classification is a big deal in today¡¯s gig economy, with app-based services from Uber to Instacart to Postmates facing similar scrutiny, and California¡¯s recently passed AB5 bill attempting to make it more difficult for these companies to classify workers as independent contractors. Classifying workers as independent contractors allows an employer to reduce labor costs, while stripping workers of potential protections, often making them ineligible for unemployment benefits and disability compensation. The National Conference of State Legislatures says a company can save up to 30 percent on labor this way, which ¡°provides a real incentive for businesses to classify their workers as independent contractors, even if the workers are truly employees.¡±

In states where there are stronger protections around freelance work, the changes don¡¯t necessarily end up helping the workers. In California, for instance, Rev no longer accepts freelance transcribers. In an email, the company¡¯s CEO, Jason Chicola, said having to remove them from the platform was ¡°devastating for us¡± and ¡°the hardest thing I¡¯ve had to do in my entire career.¡±

Revvers say they don¡¯t want the site to go away. They just want the company to pay attention to their grievances. ¡°I don¡¯t want Rev to go under,¡± says one worker. ¡°I want them to thrive, but I also want to thrive along with them.¡±

TL;DR

Yes, you can use the new Xbox Series X horizontally

Circuit Breaker

The Xbox Series X controller has a tweaked design and a Share button

Gaming

Godfall is the first game announced for the PlayStation 5

View all stories in Tech